High Court Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif has warned that the risk of witness intimidation or interference with evidence can weigh heavily in bail decisions, given the potential consequences for criminal investigations and trials.

The judge addressed the issue in her November 18 ruling on a judicial review application filed by Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed, challenging a magistrate’s decision to refuse him bail.

“Such conduct, if realised, strikes at the very foundation of the criminal justice system by threatening the integrity of evidence, the willingness of witnesses to participate in criminal proceedings and, ultimately, the proper administration of justice,” Justice Chandra-Hanif stated.

She explained that concerns about witness interference must be treated differently from the general risk of an accused person committing another offence while on bail, as such interference could directly affect the investigation and prosecution of a case.

“The assessment of risk for the purposes of bail is fundamentally different from the determination of criminal guilt. The former is necessarily prospective and preventative, whereas the latter requires proof beyond reasonable doubt,” the judge explained.

Justice Chandra-Hanif said magistrates may attach significant weight to the risk of witness interference when considering bail, even before the prosecution has presented its full case.

However, she stressed that such concerns must be supported by identifiable circumstances and cannot be based on allegations or speculation alone.

The issue was raised in Mohamed’s case, in which he faces a cybercrime charge alongside police officers. Prosecutors had expressed concerns about alleged witness interference and obstruction of justice relating to other pending criminal matters.

Justice Chandra-Hanif noted that the involvement of police officers was relevant when assessing the circumstances of the case, particularly the potential vulnerability of the investigative process.

She made clear, however, that their involvement did not automatically establish a likelihood of witness intimidation and emphasised that Mohamed remains presumed innocent of the pending charges.

The judge also considered Mohamed’s previous compliance with bail conditions imposed in other proceedings, acknowledging that this was a factor in his favour.

Nevertheless, she explained that complying with existing bail conditions does not necessarily remove concerns associated with separate proceedings, particularly where different allegations and potential risks are involved.

Justice Chandra-Hanif further stressed that protecting witnesses must be balanced against an accused person’s constitutional right to personal liberty, and that detention must meet the legal requirements for refusing bail.

“Such caution, where objectively justified and proportionate, is not synonymous with an arbitrary or unconstitutional deprivation of liberty,” she stated.

The ruling stemmed from a judicial review application filed on Mohamed’s behalf by his mother, Bonita Mohamed, challenging Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ decision to refuse him bail on a cybercrime charge involving the alleged unlawful acquisition of surveillance footage from the Guyana Police Force’s Command Centre.

The prosecution opposed bail, citing concerns about possible witness interference, obstruction of justice and the likelihood of further offences. Mohamed’s attorneys disputed those allegations and challenged the legal basis for his detention.

The High Court was therefore tasked with determining whether the magistrate had lawfully exercised her discretion under the Bail Act 2022, rather than conducting a fresh hearing on whether Mohamed should be granted bail.

.